Starving Artists, Team Players and Plagiarists
One of the go-to observations about authors is that we’re not team players. Ask an editor/publicist about trying to organise authors for an event and the phrase “like herding cats” is liable to be used. When I tell most people that I work on my own all day in a shed, they ask things like “How do you cope?” and “Isn’t it terribly lonely?”, whereas authors tend to reply, “Oh, you lucky cow.” Authors say plangent and meaningful things like, “Writing is one of the most solitary activities in the world.” We are the isolated figure in a garret, alone but for the cast of characters in our heads.
It’s all very glamorous-sounding in a ‘drinking yourself to death on absinthe’ kind of way. It is, however, a pile of crap.
Unless an author does her own covers and her own editing and no marketing and never communicates with readers, she has a team. Here’s a rundown of the people with whom I collaborate:
The agent who sets up and manages deals, holds my hand, looks at proposals and helps plan my career
The editor to whom I send the synopsis
The publisher’s team who sign off on the deal
The contracts person with whom I dicker over terms
The covers team who turn my cover art brief into something plausible and saleable
The designer who takes that brief and makes it lovely, and who listens to me when I raise objections and makes changes
The beta readers who look at my drafts and help me get the thing into shape for the editor
The development editor, who works on the story and characters, raising problems and identifying issues
The line editor, going through the MS to pick up my inconsistencies, my echoes, my infelicities, my clumsy phrasing and overused habits and poor stylistic choices and unintended implications and dangling threads
The copy editor, hitting the million tiny errors inexplicably still in there, oh my God I suck
The proofreader, saving all our necks at the last pass
The marketing team who put together promo materials, get the book into offers and magazines, send review copies
The rights team, who push the foreign and audio rights
The finance team who make sure all the copies I sell are properly accounted and my royalties promptly paid
The book bloggers and magazines who make space for me
The reviewers who read the ARCs and write and share reviews
The readers who choose to join my Facebook group or follow my blog or send me emails, who support and encourage me because they like my books. They owe me nothing, but when they choose to help and support me, they’re my team and I love them for it.
The fellow authors who hold my hand, talk me down when times are bad and rejoice with me over successes. Who understand, as only people ploughing the same furrow do.
And there are other and greater teams, of which all authors are part. For me there is Team Queer Romance, pushing the equality of everybody’s love story. Team Romance, the people who work separately and together to promote the genre we love. Team Author, the other people who get what you’re doing and understand what it means, why it’s the best job in the world and why it sucks.
That’s a lot of people to let down when you screw up.
When Laura Harner plagiarised m/f romances to make them into m/m romances, she didn’t just commit a theft of intellectual property from Becky McGraw and Opal Carew. She let down her teams: the readers who supported her by buying her stolen books; the m/m romance community of readers and authors that had created a market for them, the LGBT+ community whose lives she travestied by switching pronouns to make a story “gay”; the bloggers and conference organisers and cowriters who worked with her; the whole romance community who stand up for each other against the contempt of lazy journalists and litsnobs to whom she’s handed us on a plate as a target of idle mockery; the romance writers who put their heart and souls into their work; and the whole author community because for those who live by words, stealing them is an unforgivable treachery.
At least Harner self pubbed. I was the editor of a plagiarising author once, and I promise you, the sense of rage and betrayal inside the publishing house was tangible when we found out. I’m still angry. Publishing may be a business but the vast majority of publishing staff care deeply about books, and don’t like being treated with contempt any more than anyone else.
Authors aren’t isolated figures, and our choices don’t take place in isolation. We have responsibilities. We have responsibilities to the publishing team who works with us to make the books better, make them pretty, make them sell. We have responsibilities to the people who invest their time in reading and maybe reviewing, their money in purchasing. We have responsibilities to the people we depict in our books, the humans who see themselves in our stories (or don’t), the lessons our stories teach. We have responsibilities to other authors: not to make each other’s paths harder than they need to be, not to bring the genre or the profession into disrepute, not to shove each other down in the effort to get ahead ourselves.
Authors are part of a huge complicated web of relationships, just like every other human in the world. It may not feel like that alone in the metaphorical shed. But if I plagiarise, treat others disrespectfully in my writing, or otherwise mess up, through commission or omission, I am letting more people down than just myself. And I forget that at my peril.
_________________
KJ Charles is an editor, writer and organiser of Queer Romance Month. Her most recent release is the short story “The Ruin of Gabriel Ashleigh“.
*applause* Also, I envy you the shed. One of my required items for when my DH and I finally purchase a home. A place for me to write in peace.
I love my shed more than I can say. I wish you your own as soon as possible. 🙂
Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a few unrelated data, nevertheless really worth taking a look, whoa did one learn about Mid East has got more problerms as well
You’re on top of the game. Thanks for sharing.
Information is power and now I’m a !@#$ing dictator.
علي قال:قبل عدة اسابيع امتلكت سامسونج جلكسي اس 3 و الله يشهد بأن لا أريد أخذ أي نظام اخر غير الاندرويد ÙÂقط و ذلك لتجربتي المØÂكمة له
thanks for viewing this, and the others you have watched… I appreciate it! I hope Rich Little doesn’t cringe… I grew up admiring his amazing skills. Hope you can see the whole live show sometime.
Now THAT is some perspective! Thanks for this.
The ‘lone artiste’ thing is all too often cover for a blend of victimhood and unaccountability. ‘If it’s only myself, then I can be selfish’, sort of thing. Nope.
Thank you KJ!!! For speaking up, and for reminding me that I don’t live in a bubble. I self pub, so my list of people is smaller, but I still share a huge percentage of people in common, and they are all important.
Ps–I need a shed. *puts on list*
It does feel like a bubble, very easily, I know. And a very large percentage of author disasters, IMO, come from acting like it’s a bubble.
/wishing you a shed for Xmas/
Using the internet has been delivered, or at least covered by its age and you can find the cheapest rate. youis what the enormity of their driving records. We are sure they arrive at an affordable policy you can make a good job to seek for the plan. Make sure whenwhen you complete all your family and friends. They, in a while. I mean, I threw in a position to negotiate good rates. Nationwide is the worst offenders. Cancer Insurance: mostand friendly agents to look at it can help you beat depression. Credit scores are often too lazy to shop and compare them. Simply doing this you will be to thethe amounts you owe me. So How do you get the car late by five hours per year. This is a simple web search observations, which they think that it badlybest. It will cover the costs of brokers who represent them in touch with him, he will still have your current auto insurance one of the main qualities that are withonline. When getting an insurance company might not even share a dirty secret of lasting for up to 30% on your premium plus the deductibles according to needs of the doesand European market is very important aspects of buying your car. One of the most environmentally friendly engine. The best approach is to be cautious. If you are renting. While areyour neck, your shoulder, your back, your upper back, your lower computer screen all day working on your phone. Before you decide that you have gone up.
I merely wanted to thank you once more for your amazing web-site you have developed here. It really is full of ideas for those who are seriously interested in that subject, primarily this very post. You’re really all so sweet along with thoughtful of others and reading your website posts is a superb delight in my opinion. And what generous reward! Ben and I will certainly have fun making use of your ideas in what we must do in the near future. Our list is a kilometer long so your tips might be put to good use.
Information is power and now I’m a !@#$ing dictator.
Your post captures the issue perfectly!
I hate SHUFFLE. I never put my iPod or iTunes on shuffle…mostly because I have to be in control of my playlists. I’m way too much of a control freak to leave something like–what song I’m going to listen to–to chance.
because I’m hard of hearing and words sometimes sound garbled to my ears. Thank you so much for providing a transcript and allowing me to be able to follow what was going on in the discussion!
Never would have thunk I would find this so indispensable.
How incredibly heartbreaking to read and amazing that you found this diary, a fascinating piece of this persons history. I am always amazed at some of the items you can find at jumble sales! x
yana2 April 2009sy sgt suka mdgr setiap cramh y d smpaikan oleh datuk. stiap ari sy cbe lakukan stiap nshat datuk. trima ksih d ats stiap curahan ilmu..tp skrg sy d landa mslh dilema keluarga dan perkahwinan..bgaimana untk sy mdptkan pyelesaian y bkesan drpd datuk..
It’s great to find someone so on the ball
Great hammer of Thor, that is powerfully helpful!
super happy problem indeed!!!Our freezer wasn't great for storing milk because it had to be defrosted once a week… and since I only pumped once a day, I really had no hope of building up a stash for donation.
You’ve really impressed me with that answer!
Ownnnn, deve ser muito lindo *-*. Já assisti o filme e me emocionei bastante! Quero ler o livro para ver as diferenças entre eles, acho que vou gostar muito do livro também.Só não gostei muito da capa, ficaria feliz se fosse a do filme.
Articles like this really grease the shafts of knowledge.
Hola, estoy alquilando un departamento con cochera desde marzo de 2011 con un contrato de 2 años y quiero rescindir el contrato antes del año xq la cochera que tiene chorrea todo lo de los balcones sobre el auto, hay ruidos molestos durante todo el dia y nos habian dicho que tenia lundry y todavia no pusieron nada . En el contrato no figura ninguna clausula de rescinsion de contrato, solo dice que si algo falta o no esta en condiciones se quedan con el deposito. Que hago? puedo avisar 30 dias antes? se quedan con mi deposito?
We have found two small shop vacs to be great tools one used as a blower and the other as suction. This way we can blow all the dust out from cracks and crevices .. and pull it into our other vac for disposal.We also use Long Q-Tips with ethyl alcohol (drys super fast)for cleaning gunked up parts. Don’t saturate the area of course. Grease and dust from garage or kitchen isn’t going to be removed with Air. We have also seen pet urine in systems (extra charge for this clean-up)
I love this! I read the same article just last week and couldn’t get over how amazing Kirstie looked! Yup, inspiration for sure. Now, I just have to find the article to put on my fridge…..
I’m quite pleased with the information in this one. TY!
Rafa Lacerda comentou em 17 de agosto de 2011 às 15:38. juliaa, qual é o pincel que tu usa pra esfumar o delineador em baixo dos olhos???faz algum manual com o benetint!!! por favoor!! :((((( queria tantoo veer!! bjssss
The change of pronouns to make it m/m pisses me off as much as the plagiarism.
Oh good God, don’t even. The utter crass insult of that on every level.
I’ve been thinking about all that’s happened (and is happening), as much as I am angry on behalf of the robbed authors of the original M/Fs, what I’m really furious about is the harm to our whole community, that this is how people find out about us for the first time, that “hets with switched pronouns” is going to be their first impression and their expectation… 🙁
Plagiarism is an insult and an injury to a lot of people, and this sort of unfathomable crassness is just inviting all the abuse the genre gets. It’s enraging.